7 Memorable God Moments on ‘The Late Show’
https://relevantmagazine.com/culture/7-memorable-god-moments-on-the-late-show/
The end of The Late Show With Stephen Colbert isn’t just a scheduling shift — it’s the loss of one of mainstream television’s only places where genuine faith conversations happened without irony.
Colbert, once a Sunday school teacher, regularly made space for spiritual reflection between celebrity promo and punchlines. Whether the conversation was about Jesus, prayer, fasting or forgiveness, Colbert asked questions that went deeper than the typical “What’s next for you?” — and more often than not, guests met him there.
Here are seven thoughtful and honest faith moments from a show that never advertised itself as spiritual, but often was anyway because of its host.
Jim Gaffigan on his faith in Jesus during hard seasons
Jim Gaffigan might be the only comedian who can weave stand-up about prayer emojis into a sincere conversation about faith. “So you’re praying for me, but you’re too lazy to type out ‘I’m praying for you?’” he joked, earning a laugh from Colbert.
From there, Colbert began asking Gaffigan about his relationship with God, which Gaffigan was excited about.
“This is the only show in America where it turns to faith,” Gaffigan laughed. “And by the way, I love it.”
But he didn’t deflect. He opened up about his relationship with Jesus and the role faith played when his wife, Jeannie, was diagnosed with a life-threatening brain tumor.
Chris Pratt on spiritual discipline and surviving the spotlight
During a conversation that started with jokes about giving up sugar and ended with a reflection on spiritual burnout, Chris Pratt gave one of his most honest interviews about faith.
He had just completed the Daniel Fast, a 21-day biblical diet rooted in the Old Testament. Colbert teased him — “Daniel’s challenge was lions, not carbs” — but Pratt was surprisingly open.
“It was actually amazing,” he said, but admitted the challenge wasn’t food. It was pressure. “Sometimes [fame] does feel like a lion’s den,” he said.
Then Pratt shared a quote that had resonated with him recently: “If the spotlight that’s shining on you is brighter than the light that comes from within you, it will kill you.” It’s a line from Christine Caine that has since gone viral — and for good reason. In a culture obsessed with platform, it was a needed reminder that character still matters.
Paul Walter Hauser on sobriety, spirituality and second chances
It’s not often that an Emmy-winning actor sits on a late-night couch and immediately volunteers that his life fell apart during a shoot — but that’s exactly what Paul Walter Hauser did.
While filming Black Bird in 2023, a dark psychological drama in which he played a serial killer, Hauser told Colbert he was unraveling behind the scenes.
“I was not the best version of myself — to put it vague and safe,” he admitted.
But it was during that same shoot that he decided to get sober.
“There’s an atmosphere of dark spirituality [in New Orleans],” Hauser said. “So I got sober in the middle of the shoot and I started going to therapy. It was the catalyst for all these wonderful things that happened, including healing my family.”
Hauser didn’t shy away from the details. He pointed to the “I Am Second” bracelet on his wrist and urged viewers to watch the testimony video he and his wife recorded together.
Jimmy Carter on why he prayed for President Trump
When former President Jimmy Carter visited The Late Show in 2018, he wasn’t there to talk theology — but with Colbert behind the desk, it was inevitable.
The conversation started predictably enough: Carter was promoting his new book and offering some pointed thoughts on the political climate. But then Colbert, never one to avoid the awkward question, leaned in and asked, “Do you pray for Donald Trump?”
“I pray that he’ll be a good president and that he’ll keep our country at peace,” Carter said, “that he’ll refrain from using nuclear weapons, and that he will promote human rights.”
Andrew Garfield on Jesus, fasting and the faith found in doubt
Garfield came to the Late Show in 2017 to talk about Silence, Martin Scorsese’s film about Christian persecution in 17th-century Japan. But the real story was how preparing for the role led him to confront his own beliefs.
The actor spent a year studying with Jesuit priest the Rev. James Martin, engaging in spiritual exercises that, as Garfield described it, created a deep inner relationship with Jesus.
“It was this transformational process … where you place yourself in each New Testament scene,” he explained.
He spoke at length about finding God in ordinary things — “in the tree that was cut down to make this table” — and wrestled with the tension between belief and uncertainty.
“A life of faith is not a life of certainty,” he told Colbert. “Certainty starts war. Certainty says, ‘I know and you don’t.’ That’s terrifying to me.”
Mel Gibson and Colbert on the resurrection and the mystery of faith
When Mel Gibson sat down with Colbert in 2015, the conversation started with a plug for Hacksaw Ridge and ended somewhere in the theological deep end.
Gibson revealed that he was working on a sequel to The Passion of the Christ, titled Resurrection — but said it wouldn’t just retell the Easter story.
“It’s not just some chronological telling of just that event,” Gibson explained. “What happened in those three days? That’s worth thinking about.”
Colbert, no stranger to resurrection theology himself, leaned in. Together, they speculated on what those three days could mean, not just cinematically but spiritually.
Steph Curry on purpose, pressure and Philippians
Steph Curry has always made it clear he plays for something bigger than basketball — but on The Late Show, he broke it down.
Colbert asked about the “413” written on his shoes — a reference to Philippians 4:13.
“That’s my source of strength and determination and my purpose,” Curry said. “You’re always searching for purpose and why you’re here — and for me, that’s it.”
It was a quiet moment of clarity from one of the most competitive athletes alive, explaining the real reason he shows up.
In a media landscape that rarely takes belief seriously, Colbert created space for questions about God, doubt, purpose and grace — and he did it in front of millions, night after night.
Religion
via REL ::: RELEVANT http://www.relevantmagazine.com/rss/relevantmagazine.xml
July 18, 2025 at 05:18PM