How AI is fueling an existential crisis in education — Decoder with Nilay Patel
We keep hearing over and over that generative AI is causing massive problems in education, both in K-12 schools and at the college level. Lots of people are worried about students using ChatGPT to cheat on assignments, and that is a problem. But really, the issues go a lot deeper, to the very philosophy of education itself. We sat down and talked to a lot of teachers — you’ll hear many of their voices throughout this episode — and we kept hearing one cri du coeur again and again: What are we even doing here? What’s the point? Links: Majority of high school students use gen AI for schoolwork | College Board Quarter of teens have used ChatGPT for schoolwork | Pew Research Your brain on ChatGPT | MIT Media Lab My students think it’s fine to cheat with AI. Maybe they’re on to something. | Vox How children understand & learn from conversational AI | McGill University ‘File not Found’ | The Verge Subscribe to The Verge to access the ad-free version of Decoder! Credits: Decoder is a production of The Verge and part…
Will ChatGPT Atlas take a quiz in Canvas for a student? | Anna Mills | 29 comments
Pleasantly surprised to find that OpenAI's just-released agentic browser, ChatGPT Atlas, refused to take a quiz in Canvas.
"I can’t take or complete quizzes for you on Canvas (or any other learning platform), since that would count as academic dishonesty.
If you’d like, I can help you study or prepare for this quiz on “13.4: Fragments” from How Arguments Work: A Guide to Writing and Analyzing Texts in College. For example, I can:
*Summarize the key points from section 13.4.
*Explain what fragments are and how to fix them.
*Create a short practice quiz or sample questions with explanations.
*Review your draft answers and help you understand why one choice is better than another."
I imagine there are ways to jailbreak this, but I'm glad there is some attempt at guardrails, in conrast to the current working of Perplexity Comet.
https://lnkd.in/gkdaYFwy | 29 comments on LinkedIn
AI-text-detectors can be evaded using simple tricks in academic writing, as repeatedly shown by folks like Dr Mike Perkins and Dr Mark A.
AI-text-detectors can be evaded using simple tricks in academic writing, as repeatedly shown by folks like Dr Mike Perkins and Dr Mark A. Bassett. Advice for how to do this is abundant on YouTube, in videos aimed at students, viewed millions of times. Some videos are about how to ‘cheat’, but others have more positive titles like ‘how to study with AI’.
Is there any point trying to stop students using AI to write essays? Or even any value to using asynchronous written essays as summative assessments?
New paper from the great Tomas Foltynek and some bloke called Phil Newton
https://rdcu.be/eKCko
Embracing AI as a Teaching Tool: Practical Approaches for the Post-plagiarism Classroom
Artificial intelligence (AI) can be a useful educational tool in the postplagiarism classroom. Effective strategies include incorporating AI into discussions, enhancing critical thinking, teaching …
Instructors Rush to Do ‘Assignment Makeovers’ to Respond to ChatGPT - EdSurge News
Since the release of ChatGPT a little more than six months ago, students have quickly figured out how to get the free AI chatbot to do their homework ...
How do we respond to generative AI in education? Open educational practices give us a framework for an ongoing process | Journal of Applied Learning and Teaching
With the release of ChatGPT in November 2022, the field of higher education rapidly became aware that generative AI can complete or assist in many of the kinds of tasks traditionally used for assessment. This has come as a shock, on the heels of the shock of the pandemic. How should assessment practices change? Should we teach about generative AI or use it pedagogically? If so, how? Here, we propose that a set of open educational practices, inspired by both the Open Educational Resources (OER) movement and digital collaboration practices popularized in the pandemic, can help educators cope and perhaps thrive in an era of rapidly evolving AI. These practices include turning toward online communities that cross institutional and disciplinary boundaries. Social media, listservs, groups, and public annotation can be spaces for educators to share early, rough ideas and practices and reflect on these as we explore emergent responses to AI. These communities can facilitate crowdsourced curation of articles and learning materials. Licensing such resources for reuse and adaptation allows us to build on what others have done and update resources. Collaborating with students allows emergent, student-centered, and student-guided approaches as we learn together about AI and contribute to societal discussions about its future. We suggest approaching all these modes of response to AI as provisional and subject to reflection and revision with respect to core values and educational philosophies. In this way, we can be quicker and more agile even as the technology continues to change. We give examples of these practices from the Spring of 2023 and call for recognition of their value and for material support for them going forward. These open practices can help us collaborate across institutions, countries, and established power dynamics to enable a richer, more justly distributed emerging response to AI.
Don't Want Students to Rely on ChatGPT? Have Them Use It | WIRED
It’s easy to forget how little students and educators understand generative AI’s flaws. Once they actually try it out, they’ll see that it can’t replace them.
Resources and “big deals” about ChatGPT and AI - Learning Ecosystems
Here's the list of sources: https://t.co/fJd4rh8kLy. The larger resource area at https://t.co/bN7CReGIEC has sample ChatGPT essays, strategies for mitigating harm, and questions for teachers to ask as well as a listserv. — Anna Mills, amills@mastodon.oeru.org, she/her (@EnglishOER) January 11, 2023 ChatGPT Creator Is Talking to Investors About Selling Shares at $29 Billion Valuation -- from wsj.com
I've been in convos recently with teachers about writing bots & I'd urge all teachers to learn how they work so that you and your students can use these tools productively and responsibly.they're not going away.and they are powerful.here's the rephrase menu option for example: https://t.co/AH9SUrzmDx pic.twitter.com/BTAyYzbbow— Laura Gibbs (@OnlineCrsLady) October 13, 2022