Choosing the Right Format: How Knowledge Graph Layouts Impact AI Reasoning
Choosing the Right Format: How Knowledge Graph Layouts Impact AI Reasoning ...
š Why This Matters
Most AI systems blend knowledge graphs (structured data) with large language models (flexible reasoning). But thereās a hidden variable: "how" you translate the graph into text for the AI. Researchers discovered that the formatting choice alone can swing performance by up to "17.5%" on reasoning tasks. Imagine solving 1 in 5 more problems correctly just by adjusting how you present data.
š What They Built
KG-LLM-Bench is a new benchmark to test how language models reason with knowledge graphs.
It includes five tasks:
- Triple verification (āDoes this fact exist?ā)
- Shortest path finding (āHow are two concepts connected?ā)
- Aggregation (āHow many entities meet X condition?ā)
- Multi-hop reasoning (āWhich entities linked to A also have property B?ā)
- Global analysis (āWhich node is most central?ā)
The team tested seven models (Claude, GPT-4o, Gemini, Llama, Nova) with five ways to ātextualizeā graphs, from simple edge lists to structured JSON and semantic web formats like RDF Turtle.
š Key Insights
1. Format matters more than assumed:
Ā Ā - Structured JSON and edge lists performed best overall, but results varied by task.
Ā Ā - For example, JSON excels at aggregation tasks (data is grouped by entity), while edge lists help identify central nodes (repeated mentions highlight connections).
2. Models donāt cheat:
Replacing real entity names with fake ones (e.g., āFranceā ā āVerdaniaā) caused only a 0.2% performance drop, proving models rely on context, not memorized knowledge.
3. Token efficiency:
Ā Ā - Edge lists used ~2,600 tokens vs. JSON-LDās ~13,500. Shorter formats free up context space for complex reasoning.
Ā Ā - But concise ā always better: structured formats improved accuracy for tasks requiring grouped data.
4. Models struggle with directionality:
Ā
Counting outgoing edges (e.g., āWhich countries does France border?ā) is easier than incoming ones (āWhich countries border France?ā), likely due to formatting biases.
š Practical Takeaways
- Optimize for your task: Use JSON for aggregation, edge lists for centrality.
- Test your model: The best format depends on the LLMāClaude thrived with RDF Turtle, while Gemini preferred edge lists.
- Donāt fear pseudonyms: Masking real names minimally impacts performance, useful for sensitive data.
The benchmark is openly available, inviting researchers to add new tasks, graphs, and models. As AI handles larger knowledge bases, choosing the right ādata languageā becomes as critical as the reasoning logic itself.
Paper: [KG-LLM-Bench: A Scalable Benchmark for Evaluating LLM Reasoning on Textualized Knowledge Graphs]
Authors: Elan Markowitz, Krupa Galiya, Greg Ver Steeg, Aram Galstyan
Choosing the Right Format: How Knowledge Graph Layouts Impact AI Reasoning