Know Your Rights: What to Say (and Not Say) When Stopped by Police
https://mcdowelllawfirmllc.blogspot.com/2024/07/know-your-rights-what-to-say-and-not.html
Knowing your rights during a traffic stop is key to not making things worse. When stopped by the police, knowing what to say—and more importantly what not to say—can make all the difference. What is always the first thing cops ask you during a traffic stop?
Do you know why I pulled you over?
Why do you think they ask that question? They want you to admit wrongdoing right off the bat. If you answer anything like, “Because I was weaving,” or “I was speeding because I’m late for work,” you are making a mistake that could come back to bite you. Remember, in this day and age, most police have recording devices on their person, that can record audio and video. If you make an admission, you better believe it will make it into the police report and be used against you.
If you don’t read any further, or just look at the bold type face, I hope you remember this:
Don’t admit to anything. Less is more.
n a typical traffic stop where you were going a few miles over the speed limit, or maybe you did a rolling “California stop” at a stop sign, the stakes are pretty low. This typically isn’t going to be a life-changing event. But I have seen cases where a point or two can mean saving your license or preventing sky-rocketing insurance rates.
In some cases, saying too much can get you into hot water, and give the police cause to charge you with more offenses, or even give rise to cause for a search of your vehicle. One classic example of opening your mouth and getting in trouble is in DUI cases. Two quick examples: 1. They smell your breath and notice a “moderate odor of an unknown alcoholic beverage”. 2. You try and minimize the incident by admitting to “I only had two beers.” In both these scenarios, that can be the first step on the road towards developing probable cause for a DUI arrest.
You should be polite and say as little as possible, you have the right to remain silent. This will educate you on your rights and responsibilities during a traffic stop and give you practical advice to help you handle these situations with confidence and calm. By knowing and using your rights you can protect yourself and avoid complications that may come out of the interaction.
Your Rights
Be Polite
When stopped by the police be polite. A polite demeanor can de-escalate a situation. Being polite doesn’t mean you have to give them more information than needed. It means be calm and courteous. For example if they ask for your license and registration don’t argue. This sets a good tone and shows cooperation which can influence the officer’s attitude towards you. Being polite also protects your legal rights. Aggressive or disrespectful behavior can be perceived as suspicious and may lead to more questions or even detention. By being polite you maintain control of the situation and ensure your rights are respected during the interaction. Remember you can remain silent if the questions get too probing but do it politely. If its late or dark out, put the officer at ease. Keep your hands where they can see them. Remember, every traffic stop could potentially be very dangerous for law enforcement, so there is no need to elevate the situation.
What to Share
During a traffic stop you need to know what information you are required to share. Typically, you have to provide your driver’s license, vehicle registration and proof of insurance when asked by an officer. Beyond providing those documents, you have the right to remain silent on any other questions. If an officer asks about your destination or where you’re going or why you’re traveling, you don’t have to give detailed answers. Just tell them you’re exercising your right to remain silent. This will protect you from giving information that can be used against you later. Always keep your answers short and only to the documents asked for. By knowing what to share and what not to share you can handle the situation safer and better and keep your rights protected during the interaction. If police start asking more questions beyond what you feel comfortable answering, you can also request to speak to your attorney before you agree to answer any more questions.
When to be Silent
Knowing when to be silent during a police interaction is key to protecting your legal rights. You don’t have to answer questions beyond basic identification and vehicle related documents. If an officer asks “Do you know why I stopped you?” or asks about your recent activities you can politely decline to answer. Just say, “I don’t know,” or “I am exercising my right to remain silent”. This will prevent you from making a statement that can be misinterpreted or used against you later. If the contact continues to the point where an officer reads your Miranda rights this is a clear sign you should stop talking until you have legal representation. Remember, Miranda applies for custodial interrogation. So, if you’re being given a Miranda warning, you are likely to be arrested, or otherwise taken into custody.
Silence is not an admission of guilt it’s a strategic move to protect yourself legally. By knowing when to be silent you can de-escalate the situation and keep your rights protected during the interaction.
Traffic Stop
Answering Police Questions
When answering police questions during a traffic stop you need to balance cooperation and protecting your rights. Answer only the questions related to your basic identification and vehicle documents like your driver’s license, registration and proof of insurance. For more probing questions like “Do you know why I stopped you?” or “Have you been drinking?” be polite but firm in your answers. You can say something like “I don’t want to answer any questions without an attorney present”. This keeps the interaction respectful and protects your rights. Don’t give any unnecessary information that can be used against you. By managing your answers carefully you can make the interaction smoother and protect yourself from legal issues.
What Not to Say
During a traffic stop certain answers can escalate the situation or compromise your legal position. Don’t admit guilt or give excuses like “I didn’t know I was speeding” or “I’m just in a hurry”. These can be used as self-incriminating evidence. Don’t argue with the officer or make hostile comments this can lead to more complications and possibly more charges. Don’t volunteer information about your activities or whereabouts unless required by law. If asked where you’re coming from or going to it’s within your rights to say “I don’t want to answer”. By knowing what not to say you can protect yourself from legal risks and make the traffic stop as smooth and uneventful as possible.
This may seem like common sense, but: Don’t be a jerk. Don’t make their job any harder or give them any reason to add more charges to your case. I’ve seen hundreds of bodycam clips where I watch my clients do or say things that are regrettable, and I know will not play well in front of a jury. There’s often a part on a police report where police can check Attitude/Demeanor of the defendant. Many times, it will have the simple, “Excellent”, “Good”, Fair”, “Poor” scale. Some agencies have dozens of boxes for things like “combative”, “polite”, “cooperative” etc.
DA’s look at that portion. If the cop checked the negative boxes, it will often make negotiating with the District Attorney much more difficult. They aren’t looking to give breaks to people who mistreat other members of law enforcement.
Exercising Your Rights
Exercising your rights during a traffic stop is key to protecting your legal rights. You have the right to remain silent which means you don’t have to answer any questions beyond basic identification and vehicle documents. If the officer asks to search your vehicle you can calmly and clearly say “I don’t consent to a search”. This doesn’t mean the officer won’t potentially find another basis to search you, but it means your objection is on record which can be important if the search is challenged later. If you’re detained or arrested you have the right to an attorney. If you feel that you need the advice of legal counsel at any point during the police contact, politely exercise this right by saying, “I want to speak to an attorney”. By exercising your rights confidently and politely you can protect yourself from legal issues and make any subsequent legal proceedings fair.
If you have any questions or concerns about a traffic stop that you were involved in, please give us a call to set up a free, no obligation consultation. Our Colorado Springs law firm handles serious traffic charges, DUI, reckless driving, careless driving, driving under revocation matters, and many more.
The post Know Your Rights: What to Say (and Not Say) When Stopped by Police first appeared on McDowell Law Firm.
from McDowell Law Firm https://mcdowellfirm.com/know-your-rights-what-to-say-and-not-say/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=know-your-rights-what-to-say-and-not-say