Who claims hallowed ground? John Brown's Raid in Space, Time, and Public Memory | Society for US Intellectual History
Events organized at Harpers Ferry in 1906 and 1959 typified this duality by presenting to the public disparate interpretations of John Brown.
The first casualty occurred sometime around 1:30 am on October 17 when a raider shot and killed Heyward Shepherd, a free African American working as a porter for the B&O Railroad.
In 1906 the leaders of the Niagara Movement – precursor to the NAACP – chose to host their second annual meeting at Storer College, a historically black college in Harpers Ferry. I
“The Spirit of John Brown,” Ransom framed Brown’s actions within a religious context.<a href="applewebdata://1DE8DFA0-0973-4F57-800F-7C22784656C6#_ftn6" name="_ftnref6">[6]</a> Ransom proclaimed: “He was commissioned by the same authority and bore the same credentials as did Moses. […] he delivered a blow against slavery in the most vital part, and fired the gun whose opening shot echoed the sound of the death knell of slavery.”<a href="applewebdata://1DE8DFA0-0973-4F57-800F-7C22784656C6#_ftn7" name="_ftnref7">[7]</a> By referencing the influence of God as the reason for the raid, Ransom enforced the significance of religion in Brown’s life and challenged the assumption that insanity drove him to lead the raid.
Du Bois presented a resounding speech that projected the demands of the movement and urged members to harness the spirit of John Brown and his fellow raiders. In the conclusion of his speech, Du Bois said, that “we do not believe in violence, but we do believe in John Brown, and here on the scene of John Brown’s martyrdom we reconsecrate ourselves, our honor, and our property to the final emancipation of the race which John Brown died to make free.”
President Eisenhower approved a joint resolution for the establishment of the Civil War Centennial Commission (CWCC) in 1957.
he questions posed by NPS Staff Historian, J. Walter Coleman reinforced the CWCC’s disregard and contempt for the legacy of Brown. Some of the questions Coleman asked included: why did men follow John Brown on such a reckless scheme with no promise of results, should John Brown have been declared insane, and why did mainstream New Englanders fund his ventures.<a href="applewebdata://1DE8DFA0-0973-4F57-800F-7C22784656C6#_ftn18" name="_ftnref18">[18]</a>
The contrasting interpretations of John Brown’s Raid presented in 1906 and 1959 elucidates the enduring controversy over who can claim this hallowed ground and how historical events associated with the space appear within public memory.
Thesis statement