06: Expansion and Sectionalism

06: Expansion and Sectionalism

294 bookmarks
Custom sorting
Original Sources - An Anti-Slavery Protest (1837)
Original Sources - An Anti-Slavery Protest (1837)
William Channing's letter to Henry Clay opposing the annexation of Texas not only makes arguments against the spread of slavery, but shows a different understanding of the "purpose" of the "forwarding of the Revolution", the elevation of society and the working class - this language can support a progressive vision of government or white supremacy in promoting white labor over slavery
By this act, slavery will be spread over regions to which it is now impossible to set limits. Texas, I repeat it, is but the first step of aggressions. I trust, indeed, that Providence will beat back and humble our cupidity and ambition. But one guilty success is often suffered to be crowned, as men call it, with greater; in order that a more awful retribution may at length vindicate the justice of God, and the rights of the oppressed. Texas, smitten with slavery, will spread the infection beyond herself. We know that the tropical regions have been found most propitious to this pestilence; nor can we promise ourselves, that its expulsion from them for a season forbids its return. By annexing Texas, we may send this scourge to a distance, which, if now revealed, would appal us, and through these vast regions every cry of the injured will invoke wrath on our heads.
It is the great mission of this country, to forward this revolution, and never was a sublimer work committed to a nation. Our mission is to elevate society through all its conditions, to secure to every human being the means of progress, to substitute the government of equal laws for that of irresponsible individuals, to prove that, under popular institutions, the people may be carried forward, that the multitude who toil are capable of enjoying the noblest blessings of the social state. The prejudice, that labor is a degradation, one of the worst prejudices handed down from barbarous ages, is to receive here, a practical refutation. The power of liberty to raise up the whole people, this is the great Idea, on which our institutions rest, and which is to be wrought out in our history. Shall a nation having such a mission abjure it, and even fight against the progress which it is specially called to promote?
·originalsources.com·
Original Sources - An Anti-Slavery Protest (1837)
The war in Texas; a review of facts and circumstances, showing that this contest in the result of a long premeditated crusade against the government, set on foot by slaveholders, land speculators, &c. with the view of re-establishing, extending, and perpe
The war in Texas; a review of facts and circumstances, showing that this contest in the result of a long premeditated crusade against the government, set on foot by slaveholders, land speculators, &c. with the view of re-establishing, extending, and perpe
Ben Lundy, the man who inspired William Lloyd Garrison and then was forgotten by the taught narrative canon, argues against Texas Annexation and support for Texas in its war for Independence against Mexico. The language in this 62 page document includes descriptions of the slave power conspiracy - detailing how those opposed to slavery saw a concerted operation between "hirelings" in the press to distort Texas independence as a fight for liberty when it was exactly the opposite. He describes the cooperation between the executive and legislative branches of government, controlled by slave owners.
·archive.org·
The war in Texas; a review of facts and circumstances, showing that this contest in the result of a long premeditated crusade against the government, set on foot by slaveholders, land speculators, &c. with the view of re-establishing, extending, and perpe
Mexican-American War - Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day saints
Mexican-American War - Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day saints
The last two paragraphs of this description of the Mexican-American war presents a perspective of the War ignored by the taught narrative canon. To Mormons who had escaped the United States to Utah to practice their religion in peace, the Mexican War brought them again under the control of the US government, putting them again in the position of defending their right to practice their religion
·churchofjesuschrist.org·
Mexican-American War - Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day saints
Affidavits on Pottawatomie Massacre
Affidavits on Pottawatomie Massacre
This is the affidavit of both Martha and John Doyle. Martha's husband James, and her sons William and Drury were murdered by John Brown and his sons in June of 1855. This evidence can be put alongside the failed Harper's Ferry raid in an effort to understand who John Brown was, what he did - and how we can remember him.
·wvculture.org·
Affidavits on Pottawatomie Massacre
Interview: Producer Ric Burns | American Experience - Donner Party Documentary
Interview: Producer Ric Burns | American Experience - Donner Party Documentary
Lots of material for class discussions
Before 1846 began, California, Oregon, the entire Southwest, weren’t part of America, and Americans tended to think of their country as really going up to the Great Plains and not extending beyond that
The Donner party was part of a movement that was not just one wagon train that went wrong, but part of the whole country kind of looking to expand itself, looking to first, dream its own future, and then make it a reality. And so much of what the Donner party is about is a very tragic sense of how very potent dreams led people astray.
And one thing that is very humbling and very moving about the actual record is that you discover, really, that it’s a great tragedy that’s kind of a great democratizer. Everyone is reduced to the barest and sort of the most harrowing kind of circumstance, which is the circumstance simply to get by. And it makes you — the more you look at the record, the less you want to judge, because you understand that until you are in that similar situation, you’d have no way of really knowing how you yourself would respond.
How does tragedy a great equalizer? Is there a side of good and evil in this story?
James Reed
What about James Reed never talking about the killing of John Schneider?
One of the most striking and often noted statistics from the Donner party, which had 87 people in it, was that of the half or so who died, two thirds of the survivors — rather, two thirds of the people who survived the disaster — were women.
Almost all the women were in family units in one kind or another. In the Donner party 22 single men out of the 87 people in the Donner party — there were 22 single men who were attached to the party as teamsters, servants, drivers, hired help of one kind or another. Of the 22 single men, many of the men not in families, 19 of them died. So that pretty much accounts in and of itself for that disparate survival statistic between men and women. What it means is that if you didn’t have a family to help you, you fell by the wayside.
·pbs.org·
Interview: Producer Ric Burns | American Experience - Donner Party Documentary
A Congressman "Pleads the Case of White Men" · Wilmot's "White Man's Proviso"
A Congressman "Pleads the Case of White Men" · Wilmot's "White Man's Proviso"
How many teachers reveal the backstory to Wilmot's "proviso". It's easy and safe to only say that this is an attempt by northern congressmen to stop the expansion of slavery. It is more difficult to call this a racist attempt to keep black people out of the west. Which of these two radically different interpretations is the intended effect and which is the collateral effect?
·shec.ashp.cuny.edu·
A Congressman "Pleads the Case of White Men" · Wilmot's "White Man's Proviso"
The Gaze on Vimeo
The Gaze on Vimeo
This video has no narrative, no speech, it's just music and image. These are extended shots of the cast of the Amazon series "The Underground Railroad" shot to capture the look of the ancestors of the cast, crew, writers & directors. History teachers struggle to bring the humanity of history to their students just like these filmakers are trying to capture the humanity of their ancestors, lost to history or merely labeled as "enslaved"
e have sought to give embodiment to the souls of our ancestors frozen in the tactful but inadequate descriptor “enslaved,” a phrase that speaks only to what was done to them, not to who they were nor what they did. My ancestors – midwives and blacksmiths, agrarians and healers; builders and spiritualists, yearn’ers and doers – seen here as embodied by this wonderful cast of principal and background actors, did so very much.
·vimeo.com·
The Gaze on Vimeo
Network to Freedom (U.S. National Park Service)
Network to Freedom (U.S. National Park Service)
This is the home site to the National Park Service's effort to recognize and commemorate the underground railroad. The fact that this effort did not surface until 1998 shows how history is as much about the present as it is about the past. This country has slavery for hundreds of years, yet there was no collective, public effort to interpret the stories of those who escaped slavery until the end of the 20th century
·nps.gov·
Network to Freedom (U.S. National Park Service)
1836: A new Battle of the Alamo? - Current
1836: A new Battle of the Alamo? - Current
Short essay on the recent book "Forget the Alamo: The Rise and Fall of an American Myth" and the reaction of Texas Governor Abbott. Teachers who plow through their three bullet points on the Alamo without recognizing this bar fight over the history they're teaching are doing students a terrible disservice.
Forget the Alamo provocatively explains the true story of the battle against the backdrop of Texas’s struggle for independence, then shows how the sausage of myth got made in the Jim Crow South of the late nineteenth and early twentieth century. As uncomfortable as it may be to hear for some, celebrating the Alamo has long had an echo of celebrating whiteness.
·currentpub.com·
1836: A new Battle of the Alamo? - Current
Incidents in the life of a slave girl : Jacobs, Harriet A. (Harriet Ann), 1813-1897 :
Incidents in the life of a slave girl : Jacobs, Harriet A. (Harriet Ann), 1813-1897 :
Originally published in 1861, this autobiography could be a treasure trove of instructional material for teachers to use either as a complete source for a lesson, or for selections to be used in analysis exercises
·archive.org·
Incidents in the life of a slave girl : Jacobs, Harriet A. (Harriet Ann), 1813-1897 :
Impact of Native American Removal | Teacher Resource
Impact of Native American Removal | Teacher Resource
Several elements of this source are effective. The 3 minute video is great for 5th grade students - the Historians Perspective reading is better than any textbook summary of the Removal. Great for contextual background of another lesson
·americanindian.si.edu·
Impact of Native American Removal | Teacher Resource
Season 2: What is Manifest Destiny? - Consolation Prize
Season 2: What is Manifest Destiny? - Consolation Prize
For teachers certainly and maybe students as well. Historians show how much more there is to the term so easily thrown around in US History I classes. Sections of this could be provided to students to give them a glimpse of the complexity behind the bullet point
Manifest Destiny is a term you hear a lot when you’re learning about the history of the United States in the nineteenth century. But what is it, really? Several experts weigh in
·consolationprize.rrchnm.org·
Season 2: What is Manifest Destiny? - Consolation Prize
About this Collection | Born in Slavery: Slave Narratives from the Federal Writers' Project, 1936-1938 | Digital Collections | Library of Congress
About this Collection | Born in Slavery: Slave Narratives from the Federal Writers' Project, 1936-1938 | Digital Collections | Library of Congress
There is an extensive exhibit at the Library of Congress explain the collection and describing the advantages and disadvantages of using it to understand the past. This is a link to digitized copies. Why not have students dig into the raw material of the narratives themselves to see what they can find?
·loc.gov·
About this Collection | Born in Slavery: Slave Narratives from the Federal Writers' Project, 1936-1938 | Digital Collections | Library of Congress
Columbia University Libraries Online Exhibitions | Sydney Howard Gay’s "Record of Fugitives"
Columbia University Libraries Online Exhibitions | Sydney Howard Gay’s "Record of Fugitives"
The Record of Fugitives is a treasure trove of information about how and why slaves escaped, who assisted them, and where they were sent from New York. It contains references to well-known individuals like Harriet Tubman, who passed through New York City twice during these years, and little-known figures such as Louis Napoleon, a black porter who worked in Gay’s office and was the key operative in meeting fugitives who arrived in New York and assisting them on their journeys to freedom. But at its heart lie the arresting stories of the fugitives themselves, as Gay, an accomplished journalist, recorded them.
·exhibitions.library.columbia.edu·
Columbia University Libraries Online Exhibitions | Sydney Howard Gay’s "Record of Fugitives"
“The Whole Land is Full of Blood”: The Thomas Sims Case (U.S. National Park Service)
“The Whole Land is Full of Blood”: The Thomas Sims Case (U.S. National Park Service)
Follow the remarkable life of one man to learn about slavery, the fugitive slave clause and how difficult it is to judge people of the past - Look for Charles Devens - the US Marshall that returned Sims to slavery alter hired him as a messenger at the Justice Dept
·nps.gov·
“The Whole Land is Full of Blood”: The Thomas Sims Case (U.S. National Park Service)